The Best Steakhouses in Amarillo

The Big Texan leads for charcoal-grilled bone-in cuts and iconic Route 66 atmosphere, while Hoffbrau earns loyalty with smoked sirloin and attentive service.

By The Scoop Editorial Team · How we pick · Updated July 2026

Visiting Amarillo? Peak season runs spring and fall, when Amarillo's Steakhouses fill their best tables fast, so it pays to call ahead.

The Big Texan

★★★★★ 4.4 · 34564 reviews

Open 8 AM–10:30 PM daily

The charcoal-grilled steaks come off the pit with a smoky crust that draws Route 66 travelers and locals looking for theater with their dinner. The 32-ounce bone-in ribeye is the headliner, but standard cuts like the filet and sirloin hold their own when the dining room isn't packed. Warm yeast rolls arrive at every table, and sides like fried mushrooms, green chile corn, and loaded baked potatoes are generous. The atmosphere leans into Western camp with a gift shop and beer garden. Waits stretch past half an hour during peak hours, so call ahead or arrive early.

"Historical stop for Route 66 so we were excited to stop in. Food was delicious."Verified review

Best for: Road-trippers who want the full show

Call Now (806) 372-6000 Visit Website

7701 I-40, Amarillo

The Big Texan, Steakhouses in Amarillo — The Big TexanPhoto: The Big Texan

7701 I-40, Amarillo

2No. 2 in Amarillo

Hoffbrau Steak & Grill House

★★★★★ 4.4 · 2725 reviews

Open 11 AM–9 PM most days

The smoked sirloin here tastes closer to prime rib than standard steakhouse fare, and diners keep coming back for it. The coffee-rubbed cowboy ribeye and chicken fried steak with creamy gravy both land with proper crust and flavor. Appetizers like fried mushrooms and candied bacon set the tone before generous main courses arrive. Servers know the menu well enough to steer you toward what's working that night, and timing stays tight from first drink to last bite. The room feels welcoming without trying too hard, and portions justify the check. Private table seating is available if you want separation from the main floor. Loaded baked potatoes and cheesy grits round out most plates.

"Steak was super tender and well flavored, delicious cheesy grits."Verified review

Best for: Regulars who want consistency and value

Call Website

7203 W Interstate Hwy 40, Amarillo

Hoffbrau Steak & Grill House, Steakhouses in Amarillo — Hoffbrau Steak & Grill HousePhoto: phil hudnall

7203 W Interstate Hwy 40, Amarillo

3No. 3 in Amarillo

Ponto Gaucho Brazilian Steakhouse

★★★★★ 5 · 141 reviews

Hours vary by day

Tableside service brings a rotating parade of meats until you flip the card to stop. Filet mignon, spicy sirloin, picanha, and bacon-wrapped chicken all come hot off the grill, sliced to order. The salad bar includes a hot section, and grilled pineapple closes the meal on a caramelized note. The pace lets you control how much you eat, and quality stays high across every cut.

"Every dish was fresh, flavorful, and beautifully prepared. The meats were incredibly tender, perfectly seasoned, and cooked just right."Verified review

Best for: Big appetites and celebratory dinners

Call Website

7609 Hillside Rd, Amarillo

Ponto Gaucho Brazilian Steakhouse, Steakhouses in Amarillo — Ponto Gaucho Brazilian SteakhousePhoto: Ponto Gaucho Brazilian Steakhouse

7609 Hillside Rd, Amarillo

4No. 4 in Amarillo

Metropolitan Steak & Seafood

★★★★★ 4.6 · 563 reviews

Open 4 PM–10 PM most days, closed Sun

The beet salad and any cut off the grill make a reliable pairing. Wagyu ribeye, grilled Gulf shrimp, and fried steak with standout gravy all show precision in the kitchen. Medjool dates stuffed with blue cheese and orange sorbet bookend the meal. The bar program holds its own, and the room feels tucked away and deliberate.

"It's definitely not the cheapest place in town, but honestly, it was worth every penny."Verified review

Best for: Special occasions and steak purists

Call Website

9181 Town Square Blvd Ste 1201, Amarillo

Metropolitan Steak & Seafood, Steakhouses in Amarillo — Metropolitan Steak & SeafoodPhoto: Metropolitan Steak & Seafood

9181 Town Square Blvd Ste 1201, Amarillo

5No. 5 in Amarillo

Public House

★★★★★ 4.4 · 772 reviews

Open 11 AM–10 PM, closed Sun

The ribeye with green chile risotto and the meatloaf (made with pork, beef, and duck) anchor the menu. Thai chili chicken and a ham-and-brie sandwich with caramelized onions give non-steak eaters solid options. Live music adds energy without drowning conversation, and the patio welcomes dogs. Ooey-Gooey Butter Cake finishes things on a rich note. The vibe skews upscale comfort, and the kitchen delivers consistent quality.

Best for: Date nights with live music

Call Website

3333 Coulter St S, Amarillo

Public House, Steakhouses in Amarillo — Public HousePhoto: Rick White

3333 Coulter St S, Amarillo

How Amarillo's Top Steakhouses Compare

How Amarillo's top Steakhouses compare across key factors
Business	Price	Hours	Known for
The Big Texan Top Pick	Moderate	8 AM–10:30 PM	Road-trippers who want the full show

Hoffbrau Steak & Grill House	Moderate	11 AM–9 PM	Regulars who want consistency and value
Ponto Gaucho Brazilian Steakhouse	Not listed	Varies	Big appetites and celebratory dinners
Metropolitan Steak & Seafood	Expensive	4 PM–10 PM	Special occasions and steak purists
Public House	Expensive	11 AM–10 PM	Date nights with live music

What People Are Saying

★★★★★

32oz bone-in rib-eye, grilled to perfection over charcoal…

The Big Texan

★★★★★

Even with it being busy the gauchos and waitresses and staff had meats and refills instantly.

Ponto Gaucho Brazilian Steakhouse

★★★★★

…generous portion brought back memories of the true Texas hospitality and big-hearted servings…

Hoffbrau Steak & Grill House

Eating Steakhouses in Amarillo

Amarillo sits at the center of cattle country, with I-40 pulling highway travelers through year-round and a metro population near 204,000 that includes aerospace and energy workers looking for a good steak. The Big Texan anchors the tourist side, while newer spots serve locals celebrating promotions or anniversaries. Spring and fall bring road-trippers chasing Route 66 nostalgia; the 265 sunny days support patio dining at places like Public House, though Panhandle winds keep outdoor plans flexible. Traditional charcoal grills dominate, but Brazilian rodizio and chef-driven rooms have carved out loyal followings.

What to Know Before You Choose

Look for steakhouses that cook over charcoal or wood for proper crust and smoke (a flat-top sear won't get you there).
Bone-in cuts (ribeye, cowboy) hold more flavor than strip steaks at the same price point, and a kitchen that can handle them shows confidence.
Check whether sides come included or à la carte, because three extras can double your check at upscale spots.
Appetizers like fried mushrooms or candied bacon tell you whether the kitchen cares about the whole meal or pushes steaks only.
Brazilian rodizio makes sense for big appetites and groups, but traditional steakhouses give you more control over cook temp and cut.
Reservations matter at destination spots during weekends and holiday periods, especially if you want patio seating before the weather turns.
Ask about signature preparations (smoked sirloin, green chile risotto, specific rubs) rather than ordering a plain ribeye everywhere, the kitchen's personality shows in how they finish the plate.
Watch for operational tells like warm bread service, proper steak knives, and servers who know doneness language, these separate roadhouses from serious steak programs.

Questions Amarillo Locals Ask

Which steakhouse in Amarillo has the best atmosphere?

The Big Texan delivers full Route 66 theater with a gift shop, beer garden, and the 72-ounce challenge on stage. Public House offers live music and a pet-friendly patio for a more upscale-casual vibe. Metropolitan feels tucked away and refined, while Ponto Gaucho brings Brazilian rodizio energy. Pick the atmosphere that matches your occasion.

What's the best steak to order at Amarillo steakhouses?

Bone-in ribeye cooked over charcoal at The Big Texan gives you smoke and crust. Hoffbrau's smoked sirloin tastes like prime rib at a better price. Metropolitan's Wagyu ribeye and Public House's ribeye with green chile risotto both show precision. At Ponto Gaucho, let the tableside service bring picanha and filet until you're full.

Which Amarillo steakhouse is best for families?

The Big Texan welcomes families with a casual roadhouse vibe, warm rolls, and the spectacle of the eating challenge. Hoffbrau offers straightforward service and generous portions without fuss. Ponto Gaucho's unlimited tableside meats and salad bar keep everyone fed. Public House allows dogs on the patio and has non-steak options for picky eaters.

Do Amarillo steakhouses take reservations?

The Big Texan accepts reservations and you should use them during peak hours to avoid waits over half an hour. Ponto Gaucho fills up quickly, so call ahead. Metropolitan and Public House both welcome reservations for dinner service. Hoffbrau seats walk-ins efficiently during most hours.

What are the best appetizers at Amarillo steakhouses?

Fried mushrooms at The Big Texan and Hoffbrau both earn repeat orders. Candied bacon at Hoffbrau and medjool dates stuffed with blue cheese at Metropolitan make strong starters. Ponto Gaucho's salad bar includes hot items before the tableside meats arrive. Public House's cheese curds get mentioned often.

Which steakhouse in Amarillo offers the best value?

Hoffbrau delivers generous portions and quality at a fair price point, with smoked sirloin that punches above its cost. The Big Texan gives you atmosphere and solid cuts for moderate pricing. Ponto Gaucho's unlimited tableside service justifies the higher check if you arrive hungry. Metropolitan and Public House both charge premium but deliver upscale execution.

Are there Brazilian steakhouses in Amarillo?

Ponto Gaucho is Amarillo's Brazilian steakhouse, offering unlimited tableside service with rotating meats sliced to order. The salad bar includes hot items, and grilled pineapple closes the meal. A 10-percent military discount applies. The rodizio format lets you control the pace and variety of what you eat.

What sides should I order at Amarillo steakhouses?

Loaded baked potatoes and cowboy beans at The Big Texan, cheesy grits at Hoffbrau, and green chile risotto at Public House all stand out. Green chile corn at The Big Texan adds a local kick. Metropolitan's risotto and Ponto Gaucho's salad bar give you variety beyond the standard steak sides.

Show all 8 questions

Still deciding? You can't miss with The Big Texan, our top pick. Call The Big Texan

Visiting Amarillo? Make a trip of it Art Galleries in Amarillo Amarillo Bakeries Best Bars in Amarillo The Amarillo Breweries Guide Butcher & Meat Shops in Amarillo Amarillo Coffee & Tea

Got a correction, a tip, an opinion, or a town you want us in? Reach out, we read everything.

The Big Texan Top of the Town

Call Now