The Best Seafood Restaurants in Amarillo

Scott's Oyster Bar leads for exceptionally fresh oysters and shrimp in a no-frills room, trusted by locals for decades.

By The Scoop Editorial Team · How we pick · Updated July 2026

Visiting Amarillo? Peak season runs spring and fall, when Amarillo's Seafood Restaurants fill their best tables fast, so it pays to call ahead.

Scott's Oyster Bar

★★★★★ 4.6 · 684 reviews

Hours vary by day

Fresh seafood arrives daily at this hole-in-the-wall on Paramount, where raw oysters taste cleaner than you would expect this far inland and fried preparations come out hot and perfectly crisp. The boiled shrimp (get it spicy) and stuffed crab earn loyal crowds who pack the tight space at dinner. Fried oysters and shrimp combos anchor the menu alongside shrimp creole, all seasoned with care and cooked to order. The cookery smell fills the small dining room, and the pace stays brisk when tables fill. Diners return for the consistency and the proof that landlocked kitchens can still deliver genuine seafood when they commit to sourcing and technique.

"I have eaten fried oysters all over the US, and Caribbean. NO ONE HAS BETTER than Scott's Oyster Bar!!"Verified review

Best for: Oyster lovers seeking coastal freshness inland

Call Now (806) 354-9110

4150 Paramount Blvd, Amarillo

Scott's Oyster Bar, Seafood Restaurants in Amarillo — Scott's Oyster BarPhoto: Lazarus Powell

4150 Paramount Blvd, Amarillo

2No. 2 in Amarillo

Metropolitan Steak & Seafood

★★★★★ 4.6 · 563 reviews

Open 4 PM–10 PM most days, closed Sun

The grilled shrimp and sea bass earn as much attention as the steaks in this upscale dining room, where the chef walks the floor greeting tables and the owner packs leftovers himself. Medjool dates stuffed with blue cheese open meals that continue through perfectly cooked ribeyes and risotto finished tableside. The cocktail program delivers craft drinks alongside a wine list that supports both surf and turf choices. Located in a modern development rather than a standalone building, the interior atmosphere compensates with polished service and kitchen execution that keeps regulars coming back for special occasions and weeknight indulgences alike.

"The steak was cooked perfectly and was flavorful and delicious."Verified review

Best for: Special occasions demanding steak and seafood both

Call Website

9181 Town Square Blvd Ste 1201, Amarillo

Metropolitan Steak & Seafood, Seafood Restaurants in Amarillo — Metropolitan Steak & SeafoodPhoto: Metropolitan Steak & Seafood

9181 Town Square Blvd Ste 1201, Amarillo

3No. 3 in Amarillo

Lazy Gator

★★★★★ 4.5 · 1280 reviews

Open 11 AM–9 PM most days

The crawfish gumbo and étouffée carry real seasoning depth at this Cajun kitchen, where the grilled chicken breast arrives with house-made rub and Salmon Monica gets topped with mudbugs. The jambalaya carries real depth, the kitchen accommodates gluten-free requests, and sports play on screens without drowning out conversation.

"Good cajun food, especially since it is in Amarillo."Verified review

Best for: Cajun cravings with sports in the background

Call Website

6103 Hillside Rd, Amarillo

Lazy Gator, Seafood Restaurants in Amarillo — Lazy GatorPhoto: Eric Cannon

6103 Hillside Rd, Amarillo

4No. 4 in Amarillo

Sam's Southern Eatery

★★★★★ 4.5 · 836 reviews

Open 10 AM–9 PM most days

Fresh catfish and shrimp (fried or grilled) arrive with generous portions and friendly welcomes in this former fast-food building turned sit-down seafood spot. The crawfish po'boy and gumbo satisfy Louisiana transplants, while hush puppies and red beans complete plates that deliver serious value. Meals include little extras like bonus shrimp or hush puppies that make the family-style hospitality feel genuine. The dining room stays clean and the staff remembers faces.

"…quality food at a very good price, excellent service…"Verified review

Best for: Families wanting fresh seafood without the splurge

Call Website

4317 Teckla Blvd, Amarillo

Sam's Southern Eatery, Seafood Restaurants in Amarillo — Sam's Southern EateryPhoto: Mike Pool

4317 Teckla Blvd, Amarillo

5No. 5 in Amarillo

Drunken Oyster

★★★★★ 4.4 · 1675 reviews

Open 11 AM–12 AM most days

Charbroiled oysters arrive garlicky and N'awlins-style on the patio where live jazz plays weekends, and the blackened catfish and lobster mac show what the kitchen can do when execution lands. The Jefe sandwich and catfish bites earn repeat orders, and the elegant setting with umbrella-shaded tables draws date-night crowds. Interior lighting runs very dim, making menus hard to read when entering from daylight.

"Exceptional drinks. The food was very good. There was an acoustic artist playing and created a very enjoyable atmosphere…"Verified review

Best for: Date nights with live music and oysters

Call Website

7606 SW 45th Ave #100, Amarillo

Drunken Oyster, Seafood Restaurants in Amarillo — Drunken OysterPhoto: Drunken Oyster

7606 SW 45th Ave #100, Amarillo

How Amarillo's Top Seafood Restaurants Compare

How Amarillo's top Seafood Restaurants compare across key factors
Business	Price	Hours	Known for
Scott's Oyster Bar Top Pick	Moderate	Varies	Oyster lovers seeking coastal freshness inland

Metropolitan Steak & Seafood	Expensive	4 PM–10 PM	Special occasions demanding steak and seafood both
Lazy Gator	Moderate	11 AM–9 PM	Cajun cravings with sports in the background
Sam's Southern Eatery	Inexpensive	10 AM–9 PM	Families wanting fresh seafood without the splurge
Drunken Oyster	Expensive	11 AM–12 AM	Date nights with live music and oysters

What People Are Saying

31% of Scott's Oyster Bar reviews mention the oysters.

★★★★★

Everything we try was amazing delicious most of all it tasted like it's jus came out the ocean.

Scott's Oyster Bar

★★★★★

Everything that arrived at the table was prepared well, seasoned well, and served with obvious care.

Lazy Gator

★★★★★

The seafood was outstanding, fresh, well-seasoned, and cooked just right.

Sam's Southern Eatery

Eating Seafood in Amarillo

Seafood demand in Amarillo holds steady despite the landlocked location far from the Gulf, supported by Interstate 40 freight logistics and customers willing to pay for quality when kitchens prove they can deliver coastal freshness. The review corpus shows diners comparing local oysters and shrimp favorably to coast experiences, suggesting successful cold-chain sourcing rather than compromise. Cajun and Louisiana-style preparations dominate the higher-rated concepts, reflecting transplant populations and broader Texas Panhandle familiarity with Gulf Coast foodways. Casual formats outnumber white-tablecloth options, and most top performers operate full lunch and dinner service rather than dinner-only schedules.

What to Know Before You Choose

Fresh seafood in a landlocked market requires asking when shipments arrive and choosing kitchens with high turnover that move inventory quickly rather than letting it sit.
Oysters tell the story immediately: they should smell clean like seawater, not fishy, and raw preparations reveal freshness better than fried or charbroiled versions that mask age with heat and seasoning.
Fried seafood quality depends on oil temperature and cook-to-order discipline; limp batter or greasy coatings signal either old oil or holding fried items under heat lamps instead of serving straight from the fryer.
Cajun and Louisiana-style kitchens earn credibility through seasoning depth in gumbo and étouffée, where proper roux technique and layered spice separate authentic cooking from generic Creole cosplay.
Portion size and extras (bonus shrimp, hush puppies, sides) often correlate with value-focused kitchens that build loyalty through generosity rather than maximizing plate costs.
Atmosphere ranges from hole-in-the-wall seafood shacks to upscale dining rooms with live music; match the setting to your occasion but prioritize kitchen execution over decor when freshness matters most.
Check whether grilled options exist for anyone avoiding fried preparations, and ask about gluten-free protocols if cross-contamination from shared fryers presents a concern.

Questions Amarillo Locals Ask

Where can I get fresh oysters in Amarillo?

Scott's Oyster Bar brings in raw oysters that diners compare favorably to coastal restaurants, served both raw and fried. Drunken Oyster offers charbroiled oysters with garlic butter in the N'awlins style. Both kitchens source carefully to deliver Gulf freshness despite the distance from the coast.

Which Amarillo seafood restaurant has the best value?

Sam's Southern Eatery delivers the strongest combination of fresh seafood and budget-friendly pricing, with generous portions and bonus extras like additional shrimp or hush puppies included with meals. The quality stays consistent while prices remain accessible for families and regulars eating out multiple times a week.

Who serves authentic Cajun seafood in Amarillo?

Lazy Gator earns praise from Louisiana transplants for proper crawfish gumbo, étouffée, and jambalaya seasoned with house-made Cajun rubs. Sam's Southern Eatery also offers crawfish po'boys and gumbo with genuine flavor. Both kitchens understand the difference between Cajun cooking and generic spicy seafood.

What seafood restaurants in Amarillo are good for date night?

Metropolitan Steak & Seafood offers upscale ambiance with tableside service and craft cocktails alongside Gulf shrimp and sea bass. Drunken Oyster provides live jazz and patio seating with charbroiled oysters and an elegant setting. Both deliver atmosphere and seafood quality suitable for special occasions.

Where can I find gluten-free seafood options in Amarillo?

Lazy Gator accommodates gluten-free requests with care, offering grilled seafood preparations and menu modifications. Most Amarillo seafood kitchens can grill fish and shrimp instead of breading them, but ask about cross-contamination protocols if celiac concerns require strict separation from fried items.

Which Amarillo seafood spots have live music?

Drunken Oyster features live jazz and acoustic performances on weekends, with patio seating that pairs well with oysters and cocktails. The music adds atmosphere without overwhelming conversation, making it popular for date nights and group gatherings looking for entertainment alongside their meal.

Do any Amarillo seafood restaurants offer lunch service?

Scott's Oyster Bar, Lazy Gator, and Sam's Southern Eatery all serve lunch and dinner daily or most days. Metropolitan Steak & Seafood operates dinner-only. Lunch crowds tend to be lighter than evenings, making midday visits a good strategy for avoiding waits at popular spots.

How fresh is seafood in Amarillo given the distance from the coast?

The top Amarillo seafood kitchens source Gulf seafood daily and maintain supply chains that deliver oysters, shrimp, and fish comparable to coastal restaurants. Diners consistently report freshness that exceeds expectations for a landlocked Panhandle city. Quality depends on the restaurant's commitment to sourcing and turnover, geography included.

Show all 8 questions

Still deciding? You can't miss with Scott's Oyster Bar, our top pick. Call Scott's Oyster Bar

Visiting Amarillo? Make a trip of it Art Galleries in Amarillo Amarillo Bakeries Best Bars in Amarillo The Amarillo Breweries Guide Butcher & Meat Shops in Amarillo Amarillo Coffee & Tea

Got a correction, a tip, an opinion, or a town you want us in? Reach out, we read everything.

Scott's Oyster Bar Top of the Town

Call Now