The Best Pizza in Amarillo

575 Pizzeria leads for wood-fired crust and specialty variety, with arcade entertainment and vegan options backing the craft pizza focus.

By The Scoop Editorial Team · How we pick · Updated July 2026

Visiting Amarillo? Peak season runs spring and fall, when Amarillo's Pizza fill their best tables fast, so it pays to call ahead.

575 Pizzeria

★★★★★ 4.6 · 1089 reviews

Open 11 AM–9 PM most days, closed Sun

The wood-fired oven anchors everything here. Crust arrives blistered and perfectly baked, neither soggy nor charred, carrying a light chew that holds up under generous toppings. The Asian pizza brings ginger and sesame into unexpected harmony with the tomato base, while vegan cheese and gluten-free crust options expand the menu without compromising texture. Garlic breadsticks and Caesar salad round out the meal. The connected arcade brings pool tables, pinball, and a dance hall that hosts live music on Thursdays, making the inevitable wait for fresh pizza less tedious. Families appreciate the entertainment built into the experience.

"Expect a wait to get your fresh, delicious pizza. Thankfully, this location is huge and has plenty to keep you busy…"Verified review

Best for: families wanting entertainment with their meal

Call Now (806) 322-5575 Visit Website

2803 Civic Cir, Amarillo

575 Pizzeria, Pizza in Amarillo — 575 PizzeriaPhoto: 575 Pizzeria

2803 Civic Cir, Amarillo

2No. 2 in Amarillo

Pizza Planet

★★★★★ 4.4 · 1299 reviews

Open 10:30 AM–10 PM most days

Decades of consistency keep customers coming back. The thin-crust style stays light and crisp, loaded with toppings that outpace the national chains in both quantity and freshness. The Jalapeño Popper pizza layers cream cheese, cheddar, jalapeños, and bacon into a combination that shouldn't work on paper but delivers in practice. The J.R. Chicken Ranch and Taco pizzas follow the same generous blueprint. Chef salad arrives cold and stacked high with grilled chicken, making it a meal on its own. The lunch buffet runs Monday, Tuesday, and Friday from late morning into early afternoon, offering a budget-friendly entry point. Beer arrives in full pitchers with properly frosted mugs.

"…sitting down at Pizza Planet reminded me how big the difference is when the ingredients and dough are done right…"Verified review

Best for: value-focused diners wanting more than chains deliver

Call Website

2400 Paramount Blvd, Amarillo

Pizza Planet, Pizza in Amarillo — Pizza PlanetPhoto: Mike Pool

2400 Paramount Blvd, Amarillo

3No. 3 in Amarillo

Palio's Pizza and Bar

★★★★★ 4.5 · 796 reviews

Open 11 AM–9 PM most days

Cauliflower crust and broccoli cheese crust hold structure and flavor, avoiding the cardboard texture most alternatives deliver. The gluten-free calzone proves the kitchen takes dietary restrictions seriously. King Pepperoni and bacon jalapeño mac and cheese bring comfort without compromise. Portions lean generous. Cheesy garlic bread and spinach artichoke dip work as reliable starters.

"One of my favorite gluten-free options in Amarillo!"Verified review

Best for: gluten-free diners seeking quality texture

Call Website

3562 S Soncy Rd, Amarillo

Palio's Pizza and Bar, Pizza in Amarillo — Palio's Pizza and BarPhoto: Mike Pool

3562 S Soncy Rd, Amarillo

4No. 4 in Amarillo

Joe's Pizza & Pasta

★★★★★ 4.7 · 444 reviews

Open 10 AM–9 PM most days, closed Mon

The family ownership shows in the details. Pizza arrives with toppings like black olives and green peppers distributed evenly, not piled in the center. The Lasagna, Manicotti, and Spaghetti combo lets you sample the Italian side without committing to one dish. Chicken Parmesan and house tomato dressing earn repeat mentions. The dining room features a fountain and clean floors that signal care beyond the kitchen.

"The pizza here is sublime. It has a delicate deliciousness and exquisite freshness that exceeds expectations."Verified review

Best for: travelers wanting authentic Italian off I-40

Call

19151 I-40 Frontage Rd, Amarillo

Joe's Pizza & Pasta, Pizza in Amarillo — Joe's Pizza & PastaPhoto: Eric Moser

19151 I-40 Frontage Rd, Amarillo

5No. 5 in Amarillo

Nomad Napoletana

★★★★★ 4.7 · 249 reviews

Open 11 AM–9 PM most days

The wood-fired brick oven sits visible in the dining room, turning out thin-crust Neapolitan pies with flavorful dough that carries real character. Half-and-half specialty pizzas let you split the decision. The Pepperazzis, Buffalo chicken, and Diablo con queso bring heat and creativity, while the meatballs and honey hot wings work as solid appetizers. The downtown Polk Street location offers dog-friendly outdoor seating and nearby garage parking.

"The pizza is wood fired and was very good, meatballs were tender and not too dense…"Verified review

Best for: downtown diners wanting authentic Neapolitan pizza

Call Website

614 S Polk St, Amarillo

Nomad Napoletana, Pizza in Amarillo — Nomad NapoletanaPhoto: Nomad Napoletana

614 S Polk St, Amarillo

How Amarillo's Top Pizza Compare

How Amarillo's top Pizza compare across key factors
Business	Price	Hours	Known for
575 Pizzeria Top Pick	Moderate	11 AM–9 PM	families wanting entertainment with their meal

Pizza Planet	Inexpensive	10:30 AM–10 PM	value-focused diners wanting more than chains deliver
Palio's Pizza and Bar	Moderate	11 AM–9 PM	gluten-free diners seeking quality texture
Joe's Pizza & Pasta	Moderate	10 AM–9 PM	travelers wanting authentic Italian off I-40
Nomad Napoletana	Inexpensive	11 AM–9 PM	downtown diners wanting authentic Neapolitan pizza

What People Are Saying

★★★★★

Fresh made pizza, tasty sauce, not too acidic, great tasting crust…

575 Pizzeria

★★★★★

It has out lasted all the major chain pizza companies. It has It's own unique flavor and has been my family's go to for over 50 years…

Pizza Planet

★★★★★

Everything had a fresh, homemade quality that kept us coming back for more.

Palio's Pizza and Bar

Eating Pizza in Amarillo

Pizza demand in Amarillo stays strong across all four seasons, driven by families working in aerospace, agriculture, and the Pantex facility who treat Friday night pizza as routine rather than occasion. The city's position on I-40 brings steady traveler traffic to frontage-road spots, while downtown locations benefit from events at the Civic Center and Polk Street foot traffic. Wood-fired and Neapolitan styles have gained traction alongside hometown thin-crust institutions that have earned decades of loyalty. Gluten-free options appear across the market, reflecting broader dietary trends rather than any local quirk. The Panhandle's unpredictable weather makes carryout and delivery reliable year-round.

What to Know Before You Choose

Judge a pizza kitchen by the crust first. Wood-fired ovens deliver blistered char and chew that conventional ovens cannot replicate, so ask whether the oven runs on wood or gas before assuming Neapolitan authenticity.
Thin-crust styles should stay crisp under toppings, not sag or turn soggy halfway through the slice. New York-style needs a foldable slice that holds grease without dripping.
Specialty pizzas with unusual toppings (jalapeño popper, buffalo chicken, Asian fusion) signal a kitchen willing to experiment, but the classic pepperoni remains the best baseline test for sauce balance and cheese quality.
Gluten-free and vegan options only matter if the kitchen invests in texture and flavor. Ask whether the crust holds structure or crumbles.
Lunch buffets trade customization for value and speed. They work best when you want variety without waiting.
Carryout and delivery times vary widely. Dine-in lets you verify your order before leaving and catch errors while the pizza is still hot.

Questions Amarillo Locals Ask

Who has the best pizza in Amarillo?

575 Pizzeria leads for wood-fired crust and specialty variety. Pizza Planet holds the hometown loyalty crown with decades of thin-crust consistency. Palio's dominates the gluten-free category with cauliflower and broccoli cheese crusts. Joe's brings family-owned Italian hospitality off I-40, while Nomad Napoletana delivers authentic Neapolitan style downtown.

Where can I get gluten-free pizza in Amarillo?

Palio's Pizza leads with cauliflower crust, broccoli cheese crust, and a gluten-free calzone that all hold structure. 575 Pizzeria offers gluten-free crust alongside vegan cheese options. Most Amarillo pizza spots now carry at least one gluten-free option, but these two invest in making them taste like genuine menu items.

What pizza spots in Amarillo have entertainment for kids?

575 Pizzeria combines pizza with an arcade, pool tables, pinball machines, and a connected dance hall that hosts live music on Thursdays. The entertainment keeps families occupied during the wait for fresh wood-fired pies. Pizza Planet maintains a welcoming family atmosphere with a lunch buffet three days a week, though without dedicated game areas.

Which Amarillo pizza places offer lunch specials?

Pizza Planet runs a lunch buffet Monday, Tuesday, and Friday from late morning into early afternoon, offering a budget-friendly all-you-can-eat option. The buffet includes pizza, salad, and sides. Other spots focus on made-to-order service without buffet windows, so call ahead if timing matters for your midday meal.

Where can I find wood-fired pizza in Amarillo?

575 Pizzeria and Nomad Napoletana both use wood-fired brick ovens visible in their dining rooms. 575 leans into specialty pizzas with creative toppings, while Nomad focuses on Neapolitan-style thin crust with flavorful dough. Both deliver the blistered crust and slight char that only wood fire provides.

What's the best pizza spot near I-40 in Amarillo?

Joe's Pizza & Pasta sits directly on the I-40 frontage road, making it the most accessible option for travelers. The family-owned spot serves fresh pizza, pasta combos, and Italian entrees in a welcoming dining room. Easy on-and-off access keeps it convenient for anyone passing through the Panhandle.

Which Amarillo pizza restaurants have vegan options?

575 Pizzeria offers vegan cheese alongside gluten-free crust, letting plant-based diners build custom pizzas without sacrificing the wood-fired experience. The kitchen treats dietary restrictions as genuine menu options, not afterthoughts. Call ahead to confirm current vegan offerings before visiting other spots.

What's the pizza scene like in Amarillo compared to other Panhandle cities?

Amarillo's size supports a wider range of pizza styles than smaller Panhandle towns. Wood-fired Neapolitan, hometown thin-crust institutions, and gluten-free specialists all coexist here, while nearby Canyon and Bushland rely more heavily on national chains. The presence of families across the metro area creates steady demand for quality beyond delivery chains.

Show all 8 questions

Still deciding? You can't miss with 575 Pizzeria, our top pick. Call 575 Pizzeria

Visiting Amarillo? Make a trip of it Art Galleries in Amarillo Amarillo Bakeries Best Bars in Amarillo The Amarillo Breweries Guide Butcher & Meat Shops in Amarillo Amarillo Coffee & Tea

Got a correction, a tip, an opinion, or a town you want us in? Reach out, we read everything.

575 Pizzeria Top of the Town

Call Now