The Best Fine Dining in Amarillo

Metropolitan Steak & Seafood earns the top spot with steaks cooked to exact temp and a service team that times every refill.

By The Scoop Editorial Team · How we pick · Updated July 2026

Visiting Amarillo? Peak season runs spring and fall, when Amarillo's Fine Dining fill their best tables fast, so it pays to call ahead.

Metropolitan Steak & Seafood

★★★★★ 4.6 · 563 reviews

Open 4 PM–10 PM most days, closed Sun

The two-pound Wagyu ribeye anchors the menu, served alongside grilled Gulf shrimp that arrive hot and a beet salad that opens most meals. Medjool dates stuffed with blue cheese are the starter locals order by name, and orange sorbet clears the palate between courses. The dining room runs with the kind of attention that refills water before glasses empty and remembers orders from previous visits. The entrance sits at the base of an apartment complex, an unexpected location that gives way to a polished fine dining interior once inside.

"The quality of the food, drinks, and service more than makes up for it…"Verified review

Best for: celebrating without leaving Amarillo

Call Now (806) 242-0117 Visit Website

9181 Town Square Blvd Ste 1201, Amarillo

Metropolitan Steak & Seafood, Fine Dining in Amarillo — Metropolitan Steak & SeafoodPhoto: Metropolitan Steak & Seafood

9181 Town Square Blvd Ste 1201, Amarillo

2No. 2 in Amarillo

Public House

★★★★★ 4.4 · 772 reviews

Open 11 AM–10 PM, closed Sun

The meatloaf here runs pork, beef, and duck seared on the plancha, and it's the dish that brings diners back monthly. The ribeye with green chili risotto gets the same precision, cooked to order and plated with risotto that holds heat through the last bite. The ham and brie sandwich layers caramelized onions for lunch service, while the ooey-gooey butter cake closes dinner. Live music fills the lounge most nights without drowning conversation. The patio takes dogs and stays busy during spring and fall. The quinoa salad portion runs larger at lunch than dinner, useful to know when comparing across service windows.

"The demi-glace on the meatloaf was incredible."Verified review

Best for: upscale comfort food with a cocktail

Call Website

3333 Coulter St S, Amarillo

Public House, Fine Dining in Amarillo — Public HousePhoto: David Bleke

3333 Coulter St S, Amarillo

3No. 3 in Amarillo

O.H.M.S. Cafe & Bar

★★★★★ 4.6 · 526 reviews

Open 5:30 PM–9 PM most days, closed Sun & Mon

The elk tenderloin is the signature here, a cut locals order by name. The chocolate chile tres leches balances heat and sweet, while the roasted broccoli appetizer brings enough char to make vegetables interesting. Lunch runs a tight two-hour window, and dinner service opens later. Saturday nights fill fast.

"The atmosphere strikes the perfect balance of upscale yet comfortable…"Verified review

Best for: date night with adventurous protein choices

Call Website

619 S Tyler St, Amarillo

O.H.M.S. Cafe & Bar, Fine Dining in Amarillo — O.H.M.S. Cafe & BarPhoto: Mike Pool

619 S Tyler St, Amarillo

4No. 4 in Amarillo

Sa•vor Tapas Bar

★★★★★ 4.5 · 410 reviews

Hours vary by day

The churros arrive with dark chocolate ganache, and the patatas bravas hold their crisp through the last bite. Figs with goat cheese and stuffed peppadews round out the small plates most tables order. The bar builds drinks with real customization, and the tapas format means courses arrive when ready rather than all at once.

"Enjoyed a wonderful and welcoming friendly staff, inviting atmosphere, great cocktails, and totally delicious foods!!"Verified review

Best for: cocktails and shared plates before a show

Call Website

7669 Hillside Rd Ste 600, Amarillo

Sa•vor Tapas Bar, Fine Dining in Amarillo — Sa•vor Tapas BarPhoto: SHEILA HODGSON

7669 Hillside Rd Ste 600, Amarillo

How Amarillo's Top Fine Dining Compare

How Amarillo's top Fine Dining compare across key factors
Business	Price	Hours	Known for
Metropolitan Steak & Seafood Top Pick	Expensive	4 PM–10 PM	celebrating without leaving Amarillo

Public House	Expensive	11 AM–10 PM	upscale comfort food with a cocktail
O.H.M.S. Cafe & Bar	Expensive	5:30 PM–9 PM	date night with adventurous protein choices
Sa•vor Tapas Bar	Expensive	Varies	cocktails and shared plates before a show

What People Are Saying

★★★★★

The risotto is amazing, as was the entire meal. Exceptional service.

Metropolitan Steak & Seafood

★★★★★

Meatloaf made with Pork, Beef, and duck. Wow that was amazing and full of flavor.

Public House

★★★★★

You couldn't find a place THIS good at THIS price point in Houston.

O.H.M.S. Cafe & Bar

Eating Fine Dining in Amarillo

Steakhouses anchor Amarillo's upscale dining scene, a natural extension of the Panhandle's ranching economy and local beef access. Celebrations cluster around spring and fall when patio weather arrives, while summer heat and winter northers push diners indoors. The customer base skews toward business dinners, anniversaries, and milestone events rather than casual weeknight traffic. Reservations run heaviest Thursday through Saturday, and kitchens that handle Gulf seafood alongside steaks draw the broadest audience across Potter and Randall counties.

What to Know Before You Choose

Look for kitchens that cook steaks to exact temperature without a second trip to the grill, since consistency here signals a kitchen that knows its cuts.
Check whether the seafood menu lists Gulf sources or generic descriptions; specificity signals a kitchen that knows its supply chain.
Ask if the restaurant takes reservations for your party size, especially Thursday through Saturday when fine dining rooms fill fast.
Watch for service teams that refill water and clear courses without hovering; attentive timing matters as much as the food.
Compare whether the restaurant offers a full bar with craft cocktails or a limited wine list, since drink programs vary widely across Amarillo's upscale spots.
Note the service windows; some fine dining rooms run dinner-only while others offer lunch, and split schedules can mean limited seating.
Look for signature dishes that show up across multiple reviews by name, a sign the kitchen executes consistently rather than chasing trends.
Check if the restaurant accommodates dietary restrictions with advance notice, since fine dining menus often lean heavily on beef and butter.

Questions Amarillo Locals Ask

Which Amarillo restaurant has the best steaks?

Metropolitan Steak & Seafood earns the top spot for steaks cooked to exact specifications, with the two-pound Wagyu ribeye drawing consistent praise. Public House delivers ribeyes with green chili risotto that hold temperature through the meal. O.H.M.S. offers elk tenderloin for diners looking beyond beef.

What's the best fine dining restaurant in Amarillo for special occasions?

Metropolitan Steak & Seafood is built for celebrations, with a service team that remembers returning diners and a chef who stops by tables. O.H.M.S. Cafe & Bar brings classic fine dining atmosphere and a menu that runs from elk to fresh seafood. Public House layers in live music and a full cocktail program alongside the dining room.

Does Amarillo have good tapas restaurants?

Sa•vor Tapas Bar serves small plates including churros with dark chocolate ganache, patatas bravas, and stuffed peppadews. The bartenders customize cocktails and the room runs elegant enough for date nights. The tapas format lets you sample several dishes rather than committing to a single entrée, and the kitchen stays open late on weekends.

Which Amarillo fine dining restaurants are open for lunch?

Public House serves lunch through dinner daily except Sunday, with portions that run big on items like the quinoa salad. O.H.M.S. Cafe & Bar opens for a two-hour lunch window Tuesday through Friday before reopening for dinner. Sa•vor Tapas Bar offers brunch on weekends and lunch daily, while Metropolitan focuses on dinner service only.

Where can I get fresh seafood in Amarillo?

Metropolitan Steak & Seafood flies in Gulf seafood weekly, with grilled Gulf shrimp as a signature item. O.H.M.S. Cafe & Bar offers ahi tuna nachos and rotating seafood specials. Both kitchens handle fish with the same precision they apply to steaks, and both post seasonal catches when available.

What are the best date night restaurants in Amarillo?

O.H.M.S. Cafe & Bar handles adventurous proteins like elk tenderloin in a classic fine dining room, with desserts that finish strong. Sa•vor Tapas Bar runs a dark, intimate space where bartenders build custom cocktails. Metropolitan Steak & Seafood delivers white-tablecloth service and Gulf seafood, and all three take reservations.

Which Amarillo fine dining spots have live music?

Public House features live music most nights in the lounge area, with pianists and acoustic acts that stay background volume. The restaurant offers upscale comfort food including the three-meat meatloaf and ribeye with green chili risotto. The patio welcomes dogs and stays open during mild weather months.

Are there dog-friendly fine dining patios in Amarillo?

Public House welcomes dogs on the patio and serves the full menu outdoors, including the signature meatloaf and ribeye plates. The patio stays busy during spring and fall when Amarillo's weather runs mild. Sa•vor Tapas Bar offers outdoor seating as well, though pet policies vary by season.

Show all 8 questions

Still deciding? You can't miss with Metropolitan Steak & Seafood, our top pick. Call Metropolitan Steak & Seafood

Visiting Amarillo? Make a trip of it Art Galleries in Amarillo Amarillo Bakeries Best Bars in Amarillo The Amarillo Breweries Guide Butcher & Meat Shops in Amarillo Amarillo Coffee & Tea

Got a correction, a tip, an opinion, or a town you want us in? Reach out, we read everything.

Metropolitan Steak & Seafood Top of the Town

Call Now