The Best Pizza in Yuma

Da Boyz is Yuma's best pizza spot, known for crispy crust and generous portions at fair prices.

By The Scoop Editorial Team · How we pick · Updated July 2026

Da Boyz

★★★★★ 4.6 · 2611 reviews

Open 11 AM–8:30 PM most days

Da Boyz delivers crispy-crust pizza that sets the local standard. The house-made sausage on Da Works drives repeat orders, and the buffalo chicken with house-made ranch runs a close second. Portions are generous, prices stay reasonable, and the downtown patio with Marilyn Monroe memorabilia gives you somewhere to sit when the weather cooperates. Desserts earn their own followings, red velvet cake and cheesecake both get called out by name, and service stays fast without feeling rushed. The kitchen handles high volume without cutting corners.

"The portions are large, the bread sticks were so soft and delicious…"Verified review

Best for: Families splitting a large pie downtown

Call Now (928) 783-8383 Visit Website

284 S Main St, Yuma

Da Boyz, Pizza in Yuma — Da BoyzPhoto: Da Boyz

284 S Main St, Yuma

2No. 2 in Yuma

Bernardo's Foothills

★★★★★ 4.6 · 877 reviews

Open 10 AM–6 PM, closed Sun & Mon

The staff remembers regulars by name, which tells you how often people return for the stromboli and pizza. The green chile oil is the signature move (customers buy multiple jars to take home), the steak stromboli draws repeat praise, and The Bomb steak sandwich holds its own against the pizza menu. The owner works the floor, 70s rock plays overhead, and the cool interior has character without trying. Portions stay generous, prices stay low, and freshness shows in every order. Steak and cheese hoagies keep the sandwich crowd coming back. Calling direct is the fastest way to get your order moving.

"Delicious Stromboli that's fresh and hot! Great, friendly service from the owner makes it that much more special."Verified review

Best for: Regulars who want to be remembered

Call

11375 S Fortuna Rd Ste D, Yuma

Bernardo's Foothills, Pizza in Yuma — Bernardo's FoothillsPhoto: Bernardo's Foothills

11375 S Fortuna Rd Ste D, Yuma

3No. 3 in Yuma

Angry Italian

★★★★★ 4.6 · 396 reviews

Open 11 AM–8 PM daily

Care shows in every order, truck or brick location. The crust stands out, the stromboli rivals anything in the region, and pasta dishes (alfredo pesto ricotta, fettuccine) round out the menu. Gluten-free crust is available. The spot's tucked away, but outdoor seating and delivery make it easy once you know where to look.

"Every single staff member is always nice and they NEVER skimp out on toppings…"Verified review

Best for: Finding excellent pizza in a hidden spot

Call Website

2680 S 4th Ave, Yuma

Angry Italian, Pizza in Yuma — Angry ItalianPhoto: A. Rose

2680 S 4th Ave, Yuma

4No. 4 in Yuma

Ronnie's Pizza

★★★★★ 4.4 · 602 reviews

Open 11 AM–8 PM, closed Sun & Mon & Tue

East Coast authenticity runs through a family operation serving New York-style pizza with thin-crust, foldable slices made from family recipes, plus a Philly cheesesteak that earns its own fan base. The 28-inch party pizza handles groups. It's cash-only, no-frills, and closes at 8pm, which keeps things simple. Ingredients are fresh, orders come made-to-order, and the atmosphere leans toward function over polish.

"…ronnies is the only authentic east coast style pizza in yuma…"Verified review

Best for: Transplants missing East Coast slices

Call

2059 S Avenue A, Yuma

Ronnie's Pizza, Pizza in Yuma — Ronnie's PizzaPhoto: Ernesto Tapia

2059 S Avenue A, Yuma

5No. 5 in Yuma

Benito's Pizza

★★★★★ 4.2 · 91 reviews

Open 10:30 AM–10 PM most days

Consistent pizza quality and value on the Marine base keep orders steady. The meat lover with crispy crust gets repeat mentions, calzones (meatball and ham-and-cheese) rival the pies, and The Big Benito feeds groups for around thirty dollars. Located in the Main Exchange on MCAS Yuma, it serves personnel and families with fast delivery and generous toppings. WTI season brings wait times, so plan accordingly.

"They dont play around ingredients, you always get more than enough…"Verified review

Best for: Base families feeding a crowd cheap

Call Website

1 Marine Base MCX Food Court, Building

Benito's Pizza, Pizza in Yuma — Benito's PizzaPhoto: Anthony McCool

1 Marine Base MCX Food Court, Building

How Yuma's Top Pizza Compare

How Yuma's top Pizza compare across key factors
Business	Price	Hours	Known for
Da Boyz Top Pick	Moderate	11 AM–8:30 PM	Families splitting a large pie downtown

Bernardo's Foothills	Inexpensive	10 AM–6 PM	Regulars who want to be remembered
Angry Italian	Moderate	11 AM–8 PM	Finding excellent pizza in a hidden spot
Ronnie's Pizza	Moderate	11 AM–8 PM	Transplants missing East Coast slices
Benito's Pizza	Inexpensive	10:30 AM–10 PM	Base families feeding a crowd cheap

What People Are Saying

17% of Da Boyz reviews mention the sauce.

★★★★★

This place has the best strombolis and the workers are super friendly.

Bernardo's Foothills

★★★★★

Arguably the best NY style pizza in Yuma…

Ronnie's Pizza

★★★★★

Big slices, meat lover was phenomenal with cripsy crust…

Benito's Pizza

Eating Pizza in Yuma

Pizza demand here follows two lanes: transplants chasing thin-crust nostalgia and Italian restaurants treating pizza as one course among many. The Marine Corps Air Station drives steady base-access orders year-round, downtown spots benefit from proximity to Gateway Park, and cash-only operations with limited weekday hours reflect the town's size. Summer heat shifts volume toward takeout, while cooler months from October through April bring more dine-in traffic.

What to Know Before You Choose

Look for dough made in-house and proofed at least 24 hours, which produces better texture and flavor than same-day commercial dough.
Check whether the oven is wood-fired, deck, or conveyor: wood and deck ovens create better crust char and temperature control than fast-bake conveyors.
Ask if the mozzarella is whole-milk and low-moisture (for New York style) or fresh (for Neapolitan), since each style demands its own cheese.
Watch for sauce made from San Marzano or comparable tomatoes with minimal seasoning, not over-sugared or herb-heavy blends that mask poor ingredients.
See if they offer both thin-crust and thick-crust options, which signals a kitchen that understands multiple regional traditions rather than one formula.
Check if toppings go under the cheese (New Haven style) or over it, and whether premium proteins like house-made sausage or pepperoni are available.
Note whether slices are available all day or only at peak hours, since constant high turnover keeps product fresh.
Ask if they make their own dough balls daily on-site, which indicates a real pizza program versus reheating parbaked crusts.

Questions Yuma Locals Ask

Who has the best pizza in Yuma?

Da Boyz leads with house-made sausage on crispy crusts and a downtown patio that draws loyal fans. The buffalo chicken with house-made ranch and Da Works both draw repeat orders, and desserts like red velvet cake earn their own fans. Service stays fast, portions stay generous, and the kitchen handles volume at pace.

Where can I find New York-style pizza in Yuma?

Ronnie's Pizza serves NY-style slices with thin crusts and family recipes brought from the East Coast. The 28-inch party pizza handles groups, the Philly cheesesteak runs a strong second to the pies, and the cash-only, no-frills setup keeps things straightforward. It closes at 8pm and shuts down Sunday through Tuesday.

Which pizza spot has the best stromboli?

Bernardo's Foothills earns repeat praise for steak stromboli paired with green chile oil that customers buy by the jar. The owner works the floor, regulars get remembered by name, and prices stay low for generous portions. Calling direct gets your order moving faster than third-party apps, and the 70s rock soundtrack adds character without effort.

Are there gluten-free pizza options in Yuma?

Angry Italian offers gluten-free crust that diners say holds up well. The kitchen handles it alongside regular orders, the crust gets praised in reviews, and stromboli and pasta dishes round out the menu if you want options beyond pizza. The small location hides a bit, but outdoor seating and delivery make it accessible once you know where to look.

What's the best cheap pizza in Yuma?

Bernardo's Foothills and Benito's Pizza both run inexpensive with generous portions. Bernardo's serves stromboli and pizza with green chile oil in the Foothills, while Benito's Big Benito feeds groups for around thirty dollars on the Marine base. Both deliver quality without inflating the check, and both handle high volume during peak seasons.

Where can I get a giant pizza for a party in Yuma?

Ronnie's Pizza offers a 28-inch party pie that handles groups, while Benito's Big Benito feeds seven to ten people for roughly thirty dollars. Both spots size portions for sharing, both accept advance orders, and both deliver consistent quality at volume. Ronnie's requires cash, while Benito's sits on the Marine base and serves personnel and families.

Does anywhere in Yuma make their own sausage for pizza?

Da Boyz makes house sausage that shows up on Da Works and gets called out across reviews. The ranch is also house-made and pairs with the buffalo chicken pizza, which runs neck-and-neck with the sausage pies for repeat orders. The kitchen keeps quality high even during busy downtown nights, and the patio seating works when weather cooperates.

Which pizza places are open late in Yuma?

Da Boyz stays open until 10pm Friday and Saturday, making it the latest option for sit-down pizza downtown. Benito's runs until 10pm nightly on the Marine base. Most other spots close by 8pm or earlier and shut down multiple days a week, so weekend nights offer the widest window for late orders.

Show all 8 questions

Still deciding? You can't miss with Da Boyz, our top pick. Call Da Boyz

Got a correction, a tip, an opinion, or a town you want us in? Reach out, we read everything.

Da Boyz Top of the Town

Call Now